Bakery · Bakery · Italian · Pizza
Papa Tirozzi Bakery & Pizza
St. Johnsbury, Vermont $
The lowdown
A family-run Italian bakery, pizzeria and seafood counter on Route 2 (Portland St) west of downtown, at the former Riley's Fish Shack site. The menu spans Neapolitan-style pizza, big grinders on house-baked rolls, fried clams, haddock and lobster rolls, plus a bakery case of donuts, Italian cookies and desserts. A covered patio and lawn make it a summer favorite, and dogs are welcome outside.
What to order
From the menu.
What people say
The word around town.
Reviewers rave about fresh-baked bread and donuts, oversized subs and quality seafood, and many call it one of the best values in the area. Staff are repeatedly described as warm and accommodating, with a family atmosphere. Regulars advise calling ahead for lobster rolls.
- Google 4.7227 reviews
- Yelp 4.221 reviews
From NEKNow regulars
Been here? Tell us.
Share a photo and a few words about Papa Tirozzi Bakery & Pizza. Check in while you're here and earn a badge. First one in gets Trailblazer.
Own Papa Tirozzi Bakery & Pizza? Claim it free to update your hours, menu and photos, or get it featured at the top of St. Johnsbury and on the homepage.
Something changed?
New hours, a new menu, closed for good — tell us and we'll fix it.